Advantages
and Disadvantages of Subject Searching
Subject
searching only has a couple advantages:
- A
professional has examined the actual item to
determine what it is about and then assigns
subject headings. Therefore when you search
by subject, you can be assured
that the item is really about that topic
- Once
you know the subject heading for your specific
topic, everything that is primarily about that
topic should be listed
under the same subject heading
Subject
searching also has some disadvantages:
- The
words used in the subject heading are often
not what you would
expect (Vietnamese Conflict
instead of Vietnam War)
- You
have to type the subject
phrases exactly
(World War 1939-1945 United States instead
of World War II)
- Most
words have many synonyms
and related words (AIDS
/ Aquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome / HIV)
- Often
the subject headings use language
that has become outdated (motion
pictures instead of movies)
- Subject
headings cannot
address the contents of individual sections
of a work, such as collected
essays in a book. The subject heading will reflect
the book as a whole
For
these reasons, unless you are looking for information
about a particular person (the search term being
the person's name), keyword
searching is recommended for all
other types of topic searches. |